So, just so you know, I'm going to talk about a book that I haven't read. It's called Cinderella Ate My Daughter, by Peggy Orenstein. I will probably never read this book for a few reasons:
1. probably no one dies in it. I hate to be limited but I rarely read anything without a dead body and generally regret it unless it's by Fannie Flagg, and even her books often have dead bodies so there.
2. It's not fiction. Again, I rarely read non-fiction. I spent many years in college (more than most) reading both fiction and non-fiction. I couldn't care less for non-fiction. I would rather watch reality TV (but who wouldn't.) OK, I know a lot of people LOVE non-fiction and I respect you for being smarter and more intellectual than me. Seriously, I'm not there.
3. It's a book that I believe will probably try to scare me into thinking that pop culture is evil and that I have no influence over my own child: I got the idea it might even be focused on parents...I HATE parenting books. I have pretty much hated them since I picked up one of my first ones and it spent an entire chapter telling my why I was horrible for bringing a baby into the world at my hugely advanced age of over 40 and how my child was going to either miscarry or be damaged so don't get used to being pregnant. Yep. Don't like "parenting" books.
Having said that, why am I writing about this book? Well, she went on the Today Show. Yes. I watch the Today Show and I like I. Now that I've lost the intellectuals of the group let's get down to it: This woman was interviewed and actually wanted me to sit around and worry that my 3 1/2 year old like girly sparkly things. I get it; it's commercial. I get it; it teaches the wrong message....really?!
First, I get a bit tired of having to be alarmed and afraid about everything from transfats to bonnie bell lip-smackers. Seriously, is it so heinous that 4 and 5 year olds want to wear Bonnie Bell instead of 12 year olds. As a parents I can say no OR I can say, hey, when I was 4 or 5 I used to love it if my mom would put a touch of lipstick on me. While I would certainly object if my daughter tried to go out in make up I let her play "make up" when we're home. She wants to be like me...gosh I know I should run screaming into the woods on that one, but I just can't bring myself to do it. She also has a big thing for chapstick. What's next? Vegas and a stripper pole?
Here's an idea Penny: Let's be parents. My daughter loves princesses and dressing up. When I was little I was taunted and mocked for liking girly things (which is odd on the one hand because I was a girl BUT not so odd as I was the youngest of 4 and the only girl in my family when we were very young.) If she wants to wear a princess dress to ride her tricycle or play soccer or play shopping, so be it. She gets to have her own likes and dislikes. I refuse to be a tiger. Maybe my daughter won't turn out as good as yours, but she'll have had the chance to make decisions with guidance.
My daughter loves princesses. We read the stories and we watch the movies. There are many interpretations of fairytales. I'm sure that if I read your book you possibly don't really attack fairy tales but, I'm not going to spend my hard-earned money on your book so here's my thought and what I'm teaching my daughter to take from the "disney" versions of fairy tales:
Ariel: The hardest princess to defend. She disobeys her father to her own peril and yet lives happily ever after at 16. YIPES! We do like to point out that if Ariel had listened to her father or at least Sebastian that she wouldn't have traded her soul for a chance at true happiness...But isn't that what Ariel teaches? Sometimes you have to take chances to really get what you want? To reach for something new and different? And, honestly, isn't her dad a bit xenophobic? A great lesson in everyone trying to be a little more open to others' viewpoints.
Sleeping Beauty: She does have to be awakened by her "true love's kiss" and that works out. Frankly, the adults in this story are total losers. Seriously, the wicked fairy wins just by the parents sending her away for her entire youth and having her raised by fairies. The lesson here is that we shouldn't jump to conclusions. Probably her parents wouldn't have made her marry Philip if she really didn't want to BUT we'll never know because she and Philip fell in love etc etc.
Snow White: We do learn not to take anything from strangers even if they seem nice. Penny particularly mentions in her interview that our daughters should learn not to take apples from old witches/strangers. Well, if snow White teaches us nothing else it is this lesson. It's a lesson learned, not a model for behavior. For goodness' sakes--talk to your children about what they are watching...geeze.
Rapunzel: She believes in her dream enough to wrench herself away from a self-serving, unhealthy, emotionally abusive relationship. How bad can this be. Unless you're a self-serving, unhealthy, emotionally abusive mother you have nothing to fear from what your daughter learns from Rapunzel. Rapunzel also enjoys her talents and gifts. She has a joi de vivre that is unmatched by many characters in any movie. A sweetnes in enjoying her freedom. I want that for my daughter.
Tiana: Rocks! My daughter loves Tiana. She is even beautiful and much loved as a frog. Her beauty is not of paramount importance. She learned (from her parents) that hard work is how you get what you want, not wishing on stars or kissing frogs. I love that she is my kid's 2ns favorite.
Cinderella: She is, of course, the consummate princess. She is beautiful and abused and the prince "rescues" her. Well, I'm not so keen on that part of it either. We like to focus on Cinderella's spirit and her kindness. I also like that Cinderella always has hopes and dreams. Her fairy godmother tells her that if she didn't still hope that she couldn't have come to her. But the fairy godmother is the crux of the story. EVERY young woman needs an older woman to help her. To believe in her. To support her. Any child can blossom if someone is there for them.
In our house a princess has to have 4 qualities to be a REAL princess:
1. pretty
2. kind
3. brave
4. smart
Pretty is relative and we work on that. If you ask my kid she'll tell you the most important quality that any princess can have is to be kind. Smart and brave are the next 2. Why have pretty there? Well, we all know that princesses are pretty..it's in the script. She will tell you that all girls are princesses and that they are all pretty. It's 3-year-old logic. I'm sure she will evolve to be less kind, but I'm not sure that it will be the fault of princess culture.
Just like everything else in life, you can get a lot of different things from Disney movies and the princess culture. I choose to help my daughter take a positive message from this culture. I also help her enjoy being a girl. And if she comes home in her cinderella dress with paint or dirt on it, I don't get bent out of shape. I bought a cheap one and she fells pretty and she enjoys playing in the dirt in it. Oh well...
Also, ask me to tell you her favorite stories about Princess Ruth and the Pea and The Dread Pirate Ruth. The endings will surprise you.